(Please note: the names and locations of all parties have been changed to protect the confidentiality of the proceedings.)
Significantly, the Supreme Court in Byrd held that in Ochoa the injury-producing event was the failure to provide proper medical attention - and that observing the symptoms was sufficient for bystander emotional distress:
The injury-producing event was the failure of custodial authorities to respond significantly to symptoms obviously requiring immediate medical attention. Such a failure to provide medical assistance, as opposed to a misdiagnosis, unsuccessful treatment, or treatment that turns out to have been inappropriate only in retrospect, is not necessarily hidden from the understanding awareness of a layperson. (Bird, supra, 28 Cal.4th at p. 919-920.)
Consequently, the Plaintiffs here have properly asserted that the failure to provide proper treatment and viewing the deterioration of Sundari Patel is sufficient to claim bystander emotional distress.
The defense cites Jansen v. Children’s Hospital Medical (1973) 31 Cal.App.3d 22, the Court of Appeal held that a parent cannot claim bystander emotional distress for merely learning of the medical injury after the death of the child. She [the mother in Jansen] later learned that her child’s death was due to the failure to diagnose a penetrating duodenal ulcer. (Ochoa, supra, 39 Cal.3d at p. 167.) In contrast here, the husband and sister directly viewed a continuing injury in progress for hours. The husband and sister did not learn of the injury after the event.
Sacramento medical malpractice lawyer Blog
Go to Source
Related posts
- Study Suggests Hormone Therapy Increases Risk of Ovarian Cancer (Posted by: Salvatore J. Zambri, Esquire According to a recent Danish study, women who undergo hormone replacement therapy after menopause are at a meaningfully higher risk of developing ovarian cancer. A Reuters report states that the study, published in the Journal of the American Medical Association, comments that women who took hormone replacements were 38 percent [...])
- Hospital Fined after Deadly Blood Transfusion Error (In a disturbing case of hospital malpractice, California’s Hollywood Presbyterian Medical Center has been fined $25,000 by the state after a patient died from a blood transfusion error. In October 2008, a patient was given a blood transfusion that was later found by a Department of Public Health investigation to be unnecessary. In addition to the [...])
- No “Wrongful Life” in Canada: Supreme Court (In Canada there is no such thing as a claim for "wrongful life". In a ruling released last week, the Supreme Court of Canada denied leave to appeal a Court of Appeal decision that confirmed that Canadian law does not recognize the tort of "wrongful life" as a legitimate cause of action. In Hergott, et al. [...])
- How Do I Know if I Have a Medical Malpractice Claim? (When I am asked to review a possible claim for a client wondering if they have been a victim of medical malpractice, it often takes months of investigation and requires reviewing hundreds of pages of medical records and reports. In many cases I have to get a medical expert to provide a medical-legal opinion on [...])
- Bayer Sued Over Its Oral Contraceptive–Yaz (Posted by: Salvatore J. Zambri, Esquire Bayer reached an agreement with the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) in 2008, forcing the company to pay for a $20 million ad campaign to correct the company's history of overstating the benefits of its oral contraceptive--Yaz--and downplaying its risks. The FDA determined that Yaz carries additional risks as compared [...])
- Man From West Sacramento Files Medical Malpractice Action, Part 2 of 4 ((Please note: the names and locations of all parties have been changed to protect the confidentiality of this medical malpractice case and its proceedings.) The following four blog entries follow-up the previous two entries from July. These entries address the same issues, but do so from the defense side. By comparing the entries readers [...])
- New Program Helps Prevent Medication/Prescription Errors (24,000 Canadians Die Each Year Due to Adverse Events The Canadian Medical Association Journal has reported that each year more than 87,000 patients experience an adverse event and as many as 24,000 patients die each year due to adverse events (doctor’s code words for a bad result or a mistake). Medication Errors a Huge Problem The CMAJ [...])
- FDA Warns of Dangers of Sirolimus (Rapamune) for Liver Transplant Patients (Posted by: Salvatore J. Zambri, Esquire and Catherine Bertram, Esquire Recently, MedPage Today reported that "The FDA issued an alert regarding the risk of increased mortality in stable liver transplant patients who switch from a calcineurin inhibitor-based (CNI) immunosuppressive regimen to sirolimus (Rapamune)." It was noted, however, "that a causal relationship has not been established and [...])
- Birth Injury At Roseville Medical Facility Due To Malpractice, Part 7 of 9 ((Please note: the names and locations of all parties have been changed to protect the confidentiality of the proceedings.) THE ISSUE OF INFORMED CONSENT The defendant says that there is virtually no testimony on the issue of informed consent except Dr. Linda X.’s testimony that she failed to obtain the patient's informed consent to use [...])
- How Often Does Medical Malpractice Happen in Canada? (How often does medical malpractice happen in Canada? The short answer is that the law suits that are filed in court are just the tip of the iceberg when it comes to medical malpractice claims in Canada. medical malpractice claims in Canada tend to get a lot of attention in the media. Everyone is concerned about [...])
- What Does Informed Consent Have To Do With My Nova Scotia Medical Malpractice Claim? (medical malpractice can happen in two ways: 1. Negligence is when your doctor causes an injury because he or she failed to meet the standard expected of a reasonably competent physician; 2. Assault and Battery happens when your doctor does not have your informed consent to perform the medical procedure that caused your injury. Consent to Medical Treatment: Everyone has [...])
- What Is Medical Malpractice? (In the United States, medical malpractice is a growing problem. Medical malpractice is a medical act or decision made by a doctor or health care provider that deviates from what is accepted as a standard of practice in the medical community and leads to injury or death. Medical malpractice can result from negligence from the [...])
- Doctors Fail to Report Abnormal Test Results At Alarming Rate (Posted by: Salvatore J. Zambri, Esquire Doctors fail to report clinically significant findings to their patients in more than seven percent (7%) of the cases, according to the Associated Press, relying on a new study published Monday in the Archives of Internal Medicine. Physicians' use of electronic medical records tended to lower instances of failures to [...])
- Successful Trial Techniques – Using Technology In The Courtroom (As an experienced Baltimore, Maryland medical malpractice lawyer, I am often asked what contributes to my success. Certainly hard work comes first. But there are also various ways that can improve the odds of being successful in the courtroom. One way is to use computerized technology in the courtroom. [...])
- IV Error Results in $1 Million Wrongful Death Settlement (The family of a Vermont woman who died as a result of an IV error has been awarded a $1 million judgment in her wrongful death lawsuit. The victim, Katherine Coffey, had been admitted to Dartmouth-Hitchcock Medical Center in 2005 to be treated for fluid in her lungs following a recent open heart surgery. While undergoing [...])
- Newt Gingrich Panders To Doctors Without The Facts (Newt Gingrich is now writing opinion pieces for the Philadelphia Inquirer about the topic of tort reform. Its premise is that the real victims of malpractice claims are: The Economy and New Jobs. I guess it's timely, but where the heck is the proof for that? His examples of cases of tort reform that were passed and [...])
- Medical Malpractice Suit Against Sacramento Physician, Part 2 of 4 ((Please note: the names and locations of all parties have been changed to protect the confidentiality of the proceedings.) Question: Are medical malpractice plaintiffs eligible to recover prejudgment interest on their jury award when their statutory offer to settle has been rejected? A. Prejudgment Interest of $120,384.75: Plaintiff is entitled to Prejudgment interest, at the rate of [...])
- The Difference between Misdiagnosis and Failure to Diagnose (From a victim’s standpoint, there may not seem to be much difference between a doctor misdiagnosing your ailment and failing to diagnose it altogether. Either one could potentially result in injury and a subsequent medical malpractice claim, right? While this part is true, the law makes a clear distinction between the two. Misdiagnosing an illness typically [...])
- Pathologist Menon Should Have Been Fired Years Ago: N.B. Inquiry (Dr. Rajgopal Menon, a pathologist responsible for potentially hundreds of faulty cancer test results should have been fired years ago according to Justice Paul Creaghan 5000 + Test Results Wrong or Incomplete! Justice Creaghan is heading up an inquiry formed after an independent audit found that more than 5000 of Menon’s pathology tests for breast cancer and [...])
- Informed Consent Malpractice (The Maryland Court of Appeals has issued a new decision on the law of informed consent in Maryland medical malpractice cases. According to the court, doctors must inform patients not only of the risks of procedures but also the potential consequences of forgoing a medical procedure. The decision is a victory for patient’s rights. [...])
- Sacramento Plaintiff Must Prove Causation In Medical Malpractice Action, Part 4 of 4 ((Please note: the names and locations of all parties have been changed to protect the confidentiality of this medical malpractice case and its proceedings.) The following four blog entries follow-up the previous two entries from July. These entries address the same issues, but do so from the defense side. By comparing the entries readers [...])
- Detached Retina May Be Medical Emergency (According to a recent Johns Hopkins University Health Alert, a detached retina may be a medical emergency that can result in blindness. As you edge over age 40, the vitreous -- the clear gel-like substance inside your eyes -- begins to liquify and shrink. Within the gel are millions of fibers attached to the retina, [...])
- Doctors Forcing Patients to Sign Gag Orders (Can you believe this?! There are doctors who are forcing patients to sign a contract promising not to criticize the doctor, "his expertise and/or treatment." No signature-No medical care If the patients won’t sign the contract, the doctors won’t treat them. I will ask again: Can you flippin’ believe this?! Doctors don't like online reviews The contracts are in response to [...])
- Medical Malpractice Defenses (If you’ve been a victim of medical malpractice, you have already been subjected to injury, damages and emotional distress, even before your case makes it to trial. For this reason, it’s important to be prepared and know what to expect before you end up in court so you won’t be surprised when the defense begins [...])
- How To Find A Medical Malpractice Attorney (If you want to find a really great Medical Malpractice Attorney, take the time to research and educate yourself on medical malpractice. We will help you discover as much information as we can on our site. If you or someone you know has been the victim of medical malpractice, it is paramount that you hire a [...])